When yearbook photographer Harper and the star player of the high school football team get voted the perfect couple that never was by their senior class, the unlikely pair start falling for one another. But a handful of obstacles, including Harper's boyfriend, stand in the way of their perfect ending--
Tia likes to flirt, but she isn't looking for a serious relationship. Will is the same way--at least, that's what Tia thinks. But Will wants a real girlfriend, so despite their chemistry, he starts dating someone else. Then Tia and Will are elected their yearbook's Biggest Flirts, and things get really complicated--
Gemma thinks it is her lucky day when the star football player, Max, starts paying extra attention to her, until he asks out her best friend, Addison, and she is persuaded to spend more time together with both of them, which further complicates the situation, since Gemma still has strong feelings for Max.
After her parents separate, seventeen-year-old Zoey has a car accident she cannot remember and starts asking her high school swim team friends what happened on that night at the beach on the Florida Panhandle.